Christians and Spices
1434–1480s
Question 1
Read the source
Reported speech · written later · Verbatim
English translation by C. R. Beazley and Edgar Prestage, 1896
You cannot find a peril so great that the hope of reward will not be greater.
— Prince Henry of Portugal, reported by Gomes Eanes de Zurara; translated by C. R. Beazley and Edgar Prestage, Henry urges Gil Eanes onward, as Zurara later reported it (1434 · reported in 1453)
Prince Henry's encouragement in the excerpt is best understood in the context of which development?
- Portugal's hunt for gold, trade and allies on the coast of Africa
- Spain's competition with Portugal for lands claimed in the Americas
- Protestant and Catholic rulers competing for converts overseas
- Joint-stock companies selling shares to pay for new colonies
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (A) Portugal's hunt for gold, trade and allies on the coast of Africa
- Henry paid for voyages down the African coast to reach West African gold and trade, find Christian allies against the Muslim powers of North Africa, and win converts.
- Spain and Portugal began dividing American lands only after Columbus returned in 1493, almost sixty years after Henry spoke.
- The Protestant Reformation began in 1517, more than eighty years after Henry urged Eanes past Cape Bojador.
- Companies that sold shares to pay for overseas ventures appeared in England in the 1550s, a century after Henry's voyages.
Skill: Explain how a source fits a broader historical context
Question 2
Read the passage
Europeans began to use gunpowder (invented by the Chinese) and the sailing compass (adopted from Arab merchants who learned about it from the Chinese). Europeans also made major improvements in shipbuilding and mapmaking.
— John J. Newman and John M. Schmalbach, United States History: AP Edition, 2021
The developments described in the excerpt most directly made it possible for Portuguese crews in the 1400s to
- fix their longitude at sea by measuring the height of stars
- sail straight into the wind using broad square sails
- sail far into the open Atlantic and find their way home
- cross the Pacific Ocean to trade directly with China
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (C) sail far into the open Atlantic and find their way home
- The astrolabe measured latitude; sailors could not fix longitude reliably at sea until marine clocks were built in the 1700s.
- The lateen sail let a caravel sail closer to the wind, but no sailing ship of the time could sail straight into it.
- The compass gave direction, and caravels with lateen sails swung far out into the Atlantic to catch the winds that carried them back to Portugal.
- No European crossed the Pacific until Magellan's voyage of 1520–1521, and regular Spanish trade across it began in the 1560s.
Skill: Explain a causal relationship
Question 3
Read the source
Chronicle · his words, written later · Verbatim
English translation by C. R. Beazley and Edgar Prestage (1896 edition)
…then was it needful to part fathers from sons, husbands from wives, brothers from brothers.
— Gomes Eanes de Zurara; translated by C. R. Beazley and Edgar Prestage, Families separated at Lagos (1444 · written later in 1453)
The practice described in the excerpt most directly foreshadowed which development?
- Spanish grants of Native towns' labor to colonists in the Caribbean
- Sugar plantations worked by enslaved Africans on Atlantic islands
- English companies selling shares to pay for overseas colonies
- Spanish missions founded to convert Native peoples in New Mexico
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (B) Sugar plantations worked by enslaved Africans on Atlantic islands
- Encomienda grew out of Castile's wars against Muslim Spain and claimed the labor of Native towns, not of captives shipped from Africa.
- Portugal went on to put enslaved Africans to work growing sugar on Madeira and later São Tomé, the plantation system Europeans later carried to the Americas.
- English joint-stock companies, from the 1550s on, were a way to raise money for trade and colonies and did not grow out of slave raiding.
- Spanish missions in New Mexico began after 1598 and grew out of the Catholic drive to convert Native peoples, not the African slave trade.
Skill: Explain a connection between developments
In the Way
October 1492 – February 1493
Question 4
Read the source
Biography · Verbatim
To his simplest proposition, the spherical form of the earth, were opposed figurative texts of scripture. They observed, that in the Psalms, the heavens are said to be extended like a hide… and that St. Paul, in his epistle to the Hebrews, compares the heavens to a tabernacle, or tent, extended over the earth, which they thence inferred must be flat.
— Washington Irving, A History of the Life and Voyages of Christopher Columbus (1828)
Which evidence most directly challenges Irving's account of why Columbus's plan met opposition?
- Portugal's king turned down Columbus's request for ships in the 1480s
- Columbus cited Aristotle to argue that the ocean was narrow and easy to cross
- Ferdinand and Isabella delayed their decision until Granada had fallen
- Castile's royal advisers objected that Asia lay too far to the west to reach
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (D) Castile's royal advisers objected that Asia lay too far to the west to reach
- João II's refusal shows opposition but not its reason, and his own experts also judged Columbus's distance too short.
- Columbus's appeal to Aristotle shows his own view of a small round world, not the reasons his opponents gave.
- The monarchs' delay during the war against Granada says nothing about whether their advisers thought the Earth was flat.
- The scholars who advised Ferdinand and Isabella accepted that the Earth was round and rejected Columbus's plan because he had badly underestimated the distance to Asia.
Skill: Explain how evidence challenges a claim
Question 5
Read the source
Journal · Las Casas abstract · Markham translation · Verbatim
English translation by Clements Markham (1893 edition)
Thus, after having turned out all the Jews from all your kingdoms and lordships, in the same month of January, your Highnesses gave orders to me that with a sufficient fleet I should go to the said parts of India, and for this they made great concessions to me, and ennobled me, so that henceforward I should be called Don…
— Christopher Columbus, abstracted by Bartolomé de las Casas; translated by Clements Markham, Journal of the First Voyage (Diario), in Las Casas's abstract (1492 (Las Casas's abstract))
The arrangement Columbus describes best reflects which development in Spain in the late 1400s?
- Merchants sharing the risks of voyages through joint-stock companies
- Monarchs of a newly united kingdom seeking wealth and power overseas
- Catholic rulers competing with Protestant kingdoms for converts abroad
- City-states such as Venice paying for new sea routes to Asian markets
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (B) Monarchs of a newly united kingdom seeking wealth and power overseas
- Joint-stock companies spread risk among private investors and took hold in England after the 1550s; this bargain was made by the crown.
- Ferdinand and Isabella had joined Castile and Aragon and conquered Granada, and they backed Columbus for Asian riches, an edge over Portugal, and converts.
- The Protestant Reformation began in 1517, a generation after this voyage.
- Venice profited from the old trade routes through the eastern Mediterranean and did not sponsor Columbus; the Spanish crown did.
Skill: Explain how a source fits a broader historical context
Question 6
Read the source
Letter · Verbatim
English translation by R. H. Major (1870 edition)
…they are guileless, and so liberal of all they have that no one would believe it who had not seen it… They are not acquainted with any kind of worship, and are not idolaters… slaves, as many of these idolators as their Highnesses shall command to be shipped.
— Christopher Columbus; translated by R. H. Major, Letter to Luis de Santangel on the first voyage (February–March 1493)
Columbus most likely wrote the descriptions in the excerpt in order to
- persuade the crown that his islands were worth more voyages
- warn his sponsors that the islanders would resist Spanish rule
- argue that the islanders should be protected from enslavement
- ask the pope to grant Spain the islands that he had claimed
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (A) persuade the crown that his islands were worth more voyages
- Columbus wrote to a royal official who had helped fund the voyage and promised gold, spices, cotton and slaves to win backing for a return voyage.
- He described the islanders as guileless and generous, the opposite of a warning that they would fight Spanish rule.
- Columbus offered to ship the islanders as slaves, and in 1495 he sent hundreds of Taíno captives to Spain for sale.
- Ferdinand and Isabella, not Columbus, asked Pope Alexander VI for the grant of May 1493, and this letter went to a royal official.
Skill: Explain the purpose of a source
Question 7
Read the source
Letter · Verbatim
English translation by R. H. Major (1870 edition)
…they are guileless, and so liberal of all they have that no one would believe it who had not seen it… They are not acquainted with any kind of worship, and are not idolaters… slaves, as many of these idolators as their Highnesses shall command to be shipped.
— Christopher Columbus; translated by R. H. Major, Letter to Luis de Santangel on the first voyage (February–March 1493)
The offer at the end of the excerpt most directly foreshadowed which development?
- Portugal's purchase of captives along the coast of West Africa
- English use of indentured servants on Chesapeake tobacco farms
- Native rulers' alliances with the Spanish against local rivals
- Spanish enslavement of Native people from the Caribbean islands
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (D) Spanish enslavement of Native people from the Caribbean islands
- Portuguese raiders and traders had been taking African captives since the 1440s, so this practice came before the letter.
- Indentured servants were mostly English laborers under contract on tobacco farms in the 1600s, not Caribbean captives.
- Alliances such as Guacanagarí's came from Native rulers' own rivalries and interests, not from an offer to ship slaves.
- Columbus shipped hundreds of Taíno captives to Spain in 1495, and Spanish raiders later carried Lucayans from the Bahamas to forced labor on other islands.
Skill: Explain a connection between developments
A Line Down the Atlantic
1493–1498
Question 8
Read the source
Treaty · Verbatim
English translation (1917 edition)
…a boundary or straight line be determined and drawn north and south, from pole to pole, on the said ocean sea, from the Arctic to the Antarctic pole. This boundary or line shall be drawn straight, as aforesaid, at a distance of three hundred and seventy leagues west of the Cape Verde Islands…
— Ferdinand and Isabella of Castile and Aragon, and John II of Portugal, Treaty of Tordesillas (June 7, 1494)
The boundary described in the excerpt became the basis for which claim?
- England's claim to Newfoundland after Cabot's voyage
- France's claim to the lands along the St. Lawrence River
- Portugal's claim to Brazil on the coast of South America
- The Dutch claim to the valley of the Hudson River
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (C) Portugal's claim to Brazil on the coast of South America
- Cabot sailed for England's Henry VII in 1497, and England ignored a treaty that only Spain and Portugal had signed.
- Jacques Cartier's voyages of the 1530s gave France its claim, and France rejected the Spanish-Portuguese division.
- The line ran through eastern South America, so when Pedro Álvares Cabral reached Brazil in 1500, Portugal claimed it.
- Henry Hudson's voyage of 1609 for the Dutch gave them their claim, more than a century later and outside the treaty.
Skill: Explain a causal relationship
Question 9
Read the source
His words, written later · journal abstract · Verbatim
English translation by Clements R. Markham (1893 edition)
I… will take hence… six natives for your Highnesses, that they may learn to speak. …with fifty men they can all be subjugated and made to do what is required of them.
— Christopher Columbus, preserved in Bartolomé de las Casas's abstract; translated by Clements R. Markham, Taking people and proposing subjugation (12 and 14 October 1492)
Which development most directly challenges the expectation Columbus expressed in the excerpt?
- Guacanagarí's people unloaded the wrecked flagship and guarded its cargo
- Columbus left part of his crew on Hispaniola to search for gold
- Taíno traders offered pieces of gold in exchange for brass bells
- The fort Columbus left behind was found burned and its garrison dead
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (D) The fort Columbus left behind was found burned and its garrison dead
- Guacanagarí helped for his own political reasons, and his cooperation did not test whether a small force could rule the islanders.
- Leaving men behind shows Columbus acting on his confidence, not evidence against it.
- Trading gold for hawk's bells was exchange on Taíno terms and neither tested nor challenged a claim about conquest.
- When the second fleet reached Hispaniola in November 1493, La Navidad had been burned and every Spaniard left there was dead, which showed that Taíno communities could and did fight back.
Skill: Explain how evidence challenges a claim
Question 10
Read the passage
In 1491, the world was in many of its aspects and characteristics a minimum of two worlds—the New World, of the Americas, and the Old World, consisting of Eurasia and Africa. Columbus brought them together, and almost immediately and continually ever since, we have had an exchange.
— Alfred W. Crosby, historian and geographer, 2011, as quoted in Newman and Schmalbach, United States History: AP Edition
Which development most directly supports Crosby's claim that the exchange began “almost immediately”?
- Horses spreading north to the Great Plains through Native trade
- Spanish colonists unloading livestock and seeds on Hispaniola
- Potatoes becoming a staple crop for farming families in Ireland
- Spanish galleons carrying American silver across the Pacific
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (B) Spanish colonists unloading livestock and seeds on Hispaniola
- Horses reached the Great Plains in the 1600s, more than a century after 1492.
- Columbus's second fleet loaded calves, goats, sheep, pigs, chickens and seeds in the Canary Islands in 1493, and pigs and cattle multiplied fast on Hispaniola.
- Potatoes spread through Irish farming over the 1600s and 1700s, long after 1492.
- The Manila galleons began sailing in the 1560s and 1570s, and they moved silver rather than plants, animals or germs.
Skill: Explain how evidence supports a claim
Question 11
Read the passage
May the Devil take thee! What brought you hither? … They asked what he sought so far away from home, and he told them that we came in search of Christians and of spices.
— Anonymous member of Vasco da Gama's crew, journal of the voyage, recording two North African merchants who met a Portuguese sailor at Calicut, India, May 1498 (trans. E. G. Ravenstein, 1898)
Compared with Columbus's voyages of the 1490s, the voyage described in the excerpt
- reached the Asian markets that both kingdoms sought
- crossed the Atlantic Ocean to lands unknown to Europeans
- carried colonists and livestock to found a new colony
- was paid for by investors who had each bought shares
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (A) reached the Asian markets that both kingdoms sought
- Da Gama sailed around Africa to Calicut in 1498 and opened a sea route to the spice trade, while Columbus never reached Asia.
- Da Gama followed the African coast into the Indian Ocean, where Arab and Indian merchants already traded, while Columbus crossed the Atlantic.
- Columbus's second voyage of 1493 carried settlers and animals, while da Gama's small fleet went to trade.
- The Portuguese crown paid for da Gama's voyage; voyages paid for by shareholders, such as England's of 1553, came later.
Skill: Compare related historical developments
Enemies of the Mexica
1519
Question 12
Read the source
Florentine Codex · recorded later · our translation · Adapted
You are very welcome… Rest now; here is your house and your palaces.
— Nahua contributors and Bernardino de Sahagún; Spanish column of the Florentine Codex, Moctezuma's welcome in a later Nahua account (Encounter 8 November 1519)
In a 1520 letter to Charles V, Cortés presented this welcome as Moctezuma's surrender to Spain. Historians treat that claim with caution mainly because Cortés
- wrote his account decades after the meeting had taken place
- needed royal backing for a conquest begun without approval
- had not been present when Moctezuma spoke these words
- relied on Nahua writers who opposed Moctezuma's rule
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (B) needed royal backing for a conquest begun without approval
- Cortés wrote this letter in October 1520, less than a year after the meeting; it was Bernal Díaz who wrote decades later.
- Cortés had sailed from Cuba against the governor's orders, so he needed Charles V to accept his conquest and reward him.
- Cortés was at the meeting on the causeway, with Malintzin translating between the two leaders.
- The Nahua accounts in the Florentine Codex were gathered by Sahagún in the 1550s and later, long after Cortés wrote.
Skill: Explain how a source's purpose limits its use
Question 13
Read the source
Memoir · words written later · Verbatim
English translation by Alfred P. Maudslay, 1908
…without the help of Doña Marina we could not have understood the language of New Spain and Mexico.
— Bernal Díaz del Castillo; translated by Alfred P. Maudslay, Díaz on the language relay (about 1568)
The statement in the excerpt best supports which conclusion about the Spanish conquest of Mexico?
- Spanish soldiers had learned Nahuatl on earlier visits to the coast
- Mexica rulers chose to negotiate with the Spanish instead of fighting
- Spanish leaders depended on Native people's knowledge of languages
- Spanish horses and steel weapons decided the early battles in Mexico
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (C) Spanish leaders depended on Native people's knowledge of languages
- No Spaniard on the expedition spoke Nahuatl, which is why Cortés relied on Malintzin.
- Moctezuma did receive Cortés peacefully, but the Mexica later drove the Spanish out by force, and the statement concerns language, not Mexica strategy.
- Malintzin, a Nahua woman handed to the Spanish at Tabasco, spoke Nahuatl and Maya, and with Jerónimo de Aguilar putting her Maya into Spanish, she made talks with the Mexica possible.
- Horses and steel mattered in battle, but a statement about interpreting is not evidence about weapons.
Skill: Explain how evidence supports a claim
Question 14
Read the source
Letter · Verbatim
English translation by Francis Augustus MacNutt (1908 edition)
There is one square, twice as large as that of Salamanca, all surrounded by arcades, where there are daily more than sixty thousand souls, buying and selling, and where are found all the kinds of merchandise produced in these countries, including food products, jewels of gold and silver…
— Hernán Cortés; translated by Francis Augustus MacNutt, Second Letter to Charles V (from Segura de la Frontera) (October 30, 1520)
Reports like this one most directly encouraged which development in the following decades?
- English colonies founded to compete with Spain for Mexican trade
- Portuguese settlement on the Atlantic coast of Brazil
- An agreement dividing the ocean between Spain and Portugal
- Spanish expeditions searching for other rich empires to conquer
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (D) Spanish expeditions searching for other rich empires to conquer
- England founded no lasting American colony until Jamestown in 1607, far from Mexico.
- Portugal settled Brazil from the 1530s for brazilwood and sugar, on its side of the Tordesillas line, not because of reports from Mexico.
- Spain and Portugal signed the Treaty of Tordesillas in 1494, a generation before Cortés reached Mexico.
- News of Mexico's wealth drew Spaniards to new conquests, such as Pizarro's war on the Inca in the 1530s and the expeditions of de Soto and Coronado.
Skill: Explain a causal relationship
The Fall of Tenochtitlan
1519–1521; later population estimates
Question 15
Read the source
Letter · Verbatim
English translation by Francis Augustus MacNutt (1908 edition)
…all of which were carried in the most perfect order by eight thousand of the men; a marvellous sight to see, and it seems to me even to hear of, the bringing of thirteen small ships overland a distance of about eighteen leagues.
— Hernán Cortés; translated by Francis Augustus MacNutt, Third Letter to Charles V (from Coyoacán) (May 15, 1522)
Cortés is describing porters from Tlaxcala carrying the parts of warships to the lake around Tenochtitlan in 1521. The scene best supports which explanation of the city's fall?
- Native allies supplied much of the siege's labor and strength
- Smallpox had killed many of the city's defenders and its new ruler
- Spanish reinforcements had arrived from Cuba and from Spain
- Spanish steel and horses outmatched the weapons of the Mexica
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (A) Native allies supplied much of the siege's labor and strength
- About eight thousand Tlaxcalan porters carried the parts of thirteen warships over the mountains, and tens of thousands of Native allies fought in the siege.
- Smallpox did kill many in the city in 1520, including Cuitláhuac, but a scene of porters is evidence about allied labor, not disease.
- Some Spanish reinforcements did arrive, but Native soldiers far outnumbered Spaniards in the siege, and the porters were Tlaxcalan.
- Steel and horses helped in battle, but they could not carry a fleet over the mountains or besiege a lake city without Native armies.
Skill: Explain how evidence supports a claim
Question 16
Read the passage
The epidemic was particularly severe because, unlike in Europe, where the virus was a childhood disease, in Mexico it found “virgin soil,” striking entire households, adults as well as children, in one massive blow. With almost everyone ill at once, there was no one to provide food, water, or care so that many who fell ill died, not of smallpox, but of hunger, dehydration, and despair.
— Robert McCaa, historian, “The Peopling of Mexico from Origins to Revolution,” 2000
The epidemic described in the excerpt most directly contributed to which development?
- Cortés's seizure of Moctezuma as a hostage in 1519
- The Mexica revolt that drove out the Spanish in 1520
- Tlaxcala's alliance with the Spanish against the Mexica
- The fall of Tenochtitlan to Spanish and Native forces
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (D) The fall of Tenochtitlan to Spanish and Native forces
- Cortés took Moctezuma hostage in November 1519, a year before smallpox swept the city.
- The Mexica drove the Spanish out at the end of June 1520, before the epidemic spread through the city that autumn.
- Tlaxcala allied with Cortés in September 1519, before smallpox reached central Mexico.
- Smallpox killed many of the city's people and its new ruler, Cuitláhuac, in late 1520, weakening Tenochtitlan before the siege of 1521.
Skill: Explain a causal relationship
Question 17
Read the source
Book chapter · Verbatim
Over-work, disruption of the native economy, ecological distress, and forced relocation were much more significant than war in causing the demographic disaster, but disease remains the principal explanation for most historians, just as it was four centuries ago for the first chroniclers.
— Robert McCaa, The Peopling of Mexico from Origins to Revolution (section 2: disease and recovery) (1997 web draft)
The “demographic disaster” described in the excerpt most directly contributed to which development in Spain's American colonies?
- Spanish missionaries' arrival to convert Native peoples
- Colonists' growing use of enslaved Africans as workers
- Spain's claim to lands west of the line set at Tordesillas
- Spanish voyages in search of a western sea route to Asia
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (B) Colonists' growing use of enslaved Africans as workers
- Franciscan missionaries came to Mexico in 1524 to win converts, a religious goal that did not depend on the population collapse.
- As Native workers died, colonists bought enslaved Africans, first for Hispaniola's sugar mills by the 1520s and later for mines and plantations across the empire.
- Spain's claim rested on the Treaty of Tordesillas of 1494, decades before Mexico's population collapsed.
- Spain sought a western route to Asian spices and trade from 1492 on, not because Native populations fell.
Skill: Explain a causal relationship
Question 18
Read the source
Nahua historical account · Anderson/Dibble translation · Verbatim
English translation by Arthur J. O. Anderson and Charles E. Dibble, 1975
For in truth they thirsted mightily for gold
— Nahua collaborators of Bernardino de Sahagún; English translation by Arthur J. O. Anderson and Charles E. Dibble, Florentine Codex, Book 12: The Conquest of Mexico (about 1555–1577)
Nahua elders described the Spanish this way in an account they compiled with a Spanish friar decades after the conquest. The account is most useful to historians as evidence of
- how much gold Spain carried away from central Mexico
- the reasons Spanish soldiers gave for joining Cortés
- how Nahua people remembered and judged the invaders
- Moctezuma's private opinion of Cortés in the year 1519
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (C) how Nahua people remembered and judged the invaders
- The account gives a judgment, not a count; royal treasury records show how much gold reached Spain.
- Spanish soldiers' own reasons appear in their letters and memoirs, such as Díaz's, not in a Nahua account.
- Nahua elders told this history to Sahagún in the 1550s, so it records how the conquered remembered the Spanish hunger for gold.
- Moctezuma died in 1520, and this account was compiled by other Nahua people decades later.
Skill: Explain how a source's point of view affects its use
Small World
The 1500s
Question 19
Read the source
Research article · Verbatim
According to our most conservative estimates, the introduction of the potato accounts for approximately one-quarter of the growth in Old World population and urbanization between 1700 and 1900.
— Nathan Nunn and Nancy Qian, The Potato's Contribution to Population and Urbanization: Evidence from a Historical Experiment (May 2011)
Which development in the Americas in the 1500s contrasts most sharply with the trend described in the excerpt?
- The growth of Spanish towns such as Mexico City and Lima
- The rise of mixed populations of Spanish and Native ancestry
- The steep fall of Native populations during new epidemics
- The multiplying of pigs and cattle on Spanish ranchlands
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (C) The steep fall of Native populations during new epidemics
- Spanish towns grew in the 1500s, a trend of growth like the one in the excerpt rather than its opposite.
- Mixed populations grew in Spanish colonies, another growth trend rather than a contrast.
- While American crops later fed growth across the Old World, smallpox, measles and other diseases cut central Mexico's Native population by about 65 to 95 percent in the 1500s.
- Pigs and cattle multiplied quickly in the Americas, which parallels the growth in the excerpt rather than reversing it.
Skill: Compare related historical developments
Question 20
Read the source
Chronicle · Markham’s public-domain translation · Verbatim
English translation by Clements R. Markham, 1864
When the wind is fresh they extract much silver, but when there is no wind they cannot by any means extract silver.
— Pedro de Cieza de León; translated by Clements R. Markham, Wind furnaces at Potosí (1553)
Pedro de Cieza de León described the wind furnaces at the silver mines of Potosí in his chronicle of 1553. Silver from mines like these contributed most directly to which change in Europe?
- Merchants and bankers growing richer alongside landed nobles
- Kings relying less on bankers' loans to pay for their wars
- Protestant churches spreading across the north of Europe
- Europeans buying fewer goods from the markets of Asia
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (A) Merchants and bankers growing richer alongside landed nobles
- American silver paid for trade and backed loans, so money invested in commerce came to matter as much as land, part of the slow shift from feudalism toward capitalism.
- Spain's kings borrowed more against the silver, not less: Philip II took about two-thirds of his short-term loans from Genoese bankers and stopped payment four times.
- Protestant churches spread through religious disputes that began in 1517, almost thirty years before Potosí's silver was found in 1545.
- American silver let Europeans buy more Asian silk and porcelain, much of it through Manila after 1571.
Skill: Explain a causal relationship
Question 21
Read the source
Printed voyage account · Verbatim
The voiage intended for the discoverie of Cathay, and divers other regions, dominions, Islands, and places unknowen, set forth by the right worshipful, master Sebastian Cabota Esquire, and Governour of the mysterie and company of the Marchants Adventurers of the citie of London: which fleete being furnished, did set forth the tenth day of May, 1553.
— Richard Hakluyt, printing the record of Sir Hugh Willoughby's fleet, The voyage intended for the discovery of Cathay (1553) (1553 (printed 1589))
The London merchants named in the excerpt each bought shares to pay for this voyage. This way of raising money most directly prepared the way for
- Portugal's royal trading posts along the coasts of India
- English colonies paid for by investors, like Jamestown
- Spanish grants of Native labor to colonists in Mexico
- Spain's fleets carrying American silver back to Seville
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (B) English colonies paid for by investors, like Jamestown
- Portugal's posts in India were run by the crown, not by companies of private shareholders.
- The Virginia Company sold shares to investors and founded Jamestown in 1607, using the method these merchants had tried in 1553.
- Encomienda grants came from the Spanish crown and assigned Native labor, not shares in a venture.
- Spain's treasure fleets were convoys organized by the crown, not ventures paid for by shareholders.
Skill: Explain a causal relationship
Question 22
Read the source
Manuscript treatise · Verbatim
I. That this westerne discoverie will be greately for thinlargemente of the gospell of Christe, whereunto the princes of the refourmed relligion are chefely bounde… III. That this westerne voyadge will yelde unto us all the comodities of Europe, Affrica, and Asia… V. That this voyadge will be a greate bridle to the Indies of the Kinge of Spaine…
— Richard Hakluyt the younger, A particuler discourse concerning the greate necessitie and manifolde commodyties that are like to growe to this Realme of Englande by the Westerne discoueries lately attempted (1584)
Hakluyt's arguments are best understood in the context of which development?
- The success of England's first colony in Virginia
- France's founding of Quebec on the St. Lawrence River
- The spread of the potato as a field crop in England
- Rivalry between Protestant England and Catholic Spain
Answer and reasoning
Answer: (D) Rivalry between Protestant England and Catholic Spain
- Jamestown, England's first lasting colony, was founded in 1607, more than twenty years after Hakluyt wrote, and the Roanoke colony of the 1580s failed.
- Samuel de Champlain founded Quebec in 1608, long after Hakluyt wrote.
- Potatoes became a common field crop in England in the 1700s, and Hakluyt argued from religion, trade and rivalry with Spain.
- The Reformation had split Western Christianity, and Hakluyt urged a Protestant queen to spread her faith, win trade and check Catholic Spain in America.
Skill: Explain how a source fits a broader historical context